Best painters in Middletown
These are Middletown's top 5 painting companies ranked by our earned composite score, which weighs rating, review volume, recency, and sentiment together (see our methodology). Most of the businesses below handle both interior and exterior work, so this list covers the field as a whole rather than splitting out a specialty.
Picks are ranked by score and relevance to painter, so a lower overall score can rank higher here.
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Gardner Painting LLC | 82 | 4.8 (98) | — | Full interior & exterior jobs |
| 2 | MJ’s Painting | 70 | 4.3 (23) | — | Detail work, with close follow-up |
| 3 | Dylan's Interior Painting | 59 | 5 (2) | — | Small interior refreshes |
| 4 | Oddo's Quality Painting | 25 | — | — | Newer option, unverified track record |
| 5 | Central Ct Painting Co | 21 | — | — | Newer option, unverified track record |
1. Gardner Painting LLC
4.8 (98 reviews)score 82/100
Gardner Painting posts the strongest composite score in Middletown, backed by a 4.8 rating across 98 reviews, the most review volume on this list. Crew members like Cory, Kevin, and Darwin get named repeatedly for professional, fast work, and owners are known for replying quickly to texts before and after the job.
- Owners communicate clearly before and after the job
- Crews work quickly and clean up thoroughly, including shoes off inside
- Exterior jobs include carpentry repairs, not just paint
- Detail-oriented finishing draws repeat praise
Watch out: One customer reported three weeks of silence after an estimate visit, though this runs against the otherwise consistent communication record.
Services: interior painting, exterior painting, cabinet refinishing, pressure washing
2. MJ’s Painting
4.3 (23 reviews)score 70/100
MJ's Painting has a 4.3 rating from 23 reviews, and older reviews describe detail-oriented work finished on schedule, including praised cabinet refinishing. More recent reviews over the past year tell a different story, with reports of stalled communication and unfinished work once a deposit is down, so treat this as a lower-confidence pick.
- Strong detail work and fair pricing on cabinet jobs
- Quick turnarounds reported in earlier projects
- Professional crew when actively engaged on a job
Watch out: Recent reviews describe communication dropping off, and jobs stalling, after a deposit or partway through the work.
Services: cabinet refinishing, pressure washing, interior painting, exterior painting
3. Dylan's Interior Painting
5 (2 reviews)score 59/100
Dylan's Interior Painting has just 2 reviews so far, both positive, describing a two-bedroom job with popcorn ceiling removal finished on schedule. The sample is small, so this is a lower-confidence pick worth verifying with the business directly before committing to a larger project.
- Responsive to scheduling requests
- Efficient turnaround on the jobs reviewed
Services: cabinet refinishing, interior painting, wallpaper installation, pressure washing
4. Oddo's Quality Painting
score 25/100
Oddo's Quality Painting doesn't yet have customer reviews on record, so there isn't a sentiment history to point to one way or the other. It's included here on completeness of its profile, but worth a direct conversation about references before booking.
- Profile listed with painting services in Middletown
Watch out: No customer reviews yet, so quality and reliability can't be verified from review data.
Services: interior painting, commercial painting
5. Central Ct Painting Co
score 21/100
Central Ct Painting Co also has no customer reviews on record yet, putting it at the lower end of the composite score for now. It rounds out the local field of options but comes with the least amount of public feedback to go on.
- Profile listed with painting services in Middletown
Watch out: No customer reviews yet, so it's worth asking for references directly.
Services: interior painting, exterior painting, licensed insured, commercial painting
How was this ranking calculated?
| Signal | Weight |
|---|---|
| Review sentiment | 28% |
| Google rating | 26% |
| Review volume | 20% |
| Profile completeness | 15% |
| Review recency | 11% |
Ranking data checked 2026-09-01 · Full methodology ›