Compare 6 Middletown painters that refinish and repaint kitchen and bath cabinets. Learn what the job involves, what to check, and how we score.
Cabinet refinishing means giving existing cabinets a new painted or stained finish without tearing out the boxes. A good job takes doors and drawer fronts off, labels the hardware, degreases and sands every surface, fills damage, primes with a bonding primer, and applies two or more coats of a hard-wearing cabinet enamel. Most of the work happens in the prep, not the final coat.
We list 6 Middletown businesses in this category and score them on the same criteria, so you can compare them side by side. See how we score for the details, then check the ranked guide to Middletown painters to see which ones rate highest overall before you ask for quotes.
Find cabinet refinishing & repainting in Middletown for your project
No cost, no obligation. Describe your painting work and we'll connect you with qualified painters.
6 businesses, scored on recent reviews. The order weighs each business's overall score by how much of its reviewed work is cabinet refinishing & repainting, so a lower-scored specialist can rank above a higher-scored generalist.
Dylan completed interior painting on two bedrooms with popcorn ceiling removal on schedule and responded quickly to customer requests. Work was finished efficiently.
All 20 recent reviewers rate Davis Painting five stars, citing professional workmanship, fair pricing, and responsiveness from start to finish. Shea is named as a standout contact who listens carefully and delivers results on time or ahead of schedule. Reviewers praise the crew's attention to detail and trustworthiness, especially when homeowners are not present during the job. Interior and garage projects dominate the feedback, with customers reporting work that meets or exceeds expectations. No complaints appear in recent reviews.
Gardner Painting delivers consistent work across interior and exterior projects, with crew members like Cory, Kevin, and Darwin earning repeat praise for professionalism and speed. Most jobs wrap on time, crews clean thoroughly (including taking shoes off inside), and owners reply quickly to texts. One reviewer waited three weeks without contact after an estimate visit, a sharp contrast to the norm.
Strong work quality when engaged, but recent reviews highlight a troubling pattern: once deposits are taken or projects start, communication collapses. Older five-star reviews praise detail, speed, and professionalism. Recent one-star reviews (past year) report abandoned jobs, poor prep, and Marc Jr. ignoring calls for months. The company appears to deliver when actively managing a job but struggles with follow-through and accountability once payment is received.
Seven of eight reviews praise Erick's attention to detail, crew responsiveness, and willingness to do extra work unpaid. One recent complaint details repeated scheduling delays, a sudden quote nearly doubled hours before start, and job cancellation when the customer questioned the change. Most reviewers report professional, punctual crews who protect homes and offer thoughtful color advice.
Find cabinet refinishing & repainting in Middletown for your project
No cost, no obligation. Describe your painting work and we'll connect you with qualified painters.
Two reviewers praised Matt and the crew for meticulous, trustworthy work. One homeowner reported paint peeling on multiple walls four years after the job, citing missing primer and questioning the owner's expired license. Evidence is thin (only three reviews).
When you submit a quote or contact form, your enquiry may be shared with partner providers who can do the work. We may receive a referral fee for this, but our rankings and scores are based solely on our published method and are not influenced by referral fees.
Last updated 2026-10-02